My First-Ever Online Date From Hot or Not in 2004

My First-Ever Online Date From Hot or Not in 2004

Let me tell you the story of my first-ever online date, from Hot or Not back in 2004. You think today's apps are bad? Back then all you had was a single picture — no swiping, no photo dumps. One headshot, and you clicked "hot" or "not."

One picture, one bad surprise

I clicked "hot" on a girl with what I thought was a pretty headshot and started messaging to set up a date. This was in Columbia, South Carolina, fall 2004 — I was a 20-year-old sophomore living in an apartment with three friends. Then, right before the date, she put up a new picture, and I had a feeling things might not match what I'd pictured. But I'd already scheduled it, so off I went.

"Keep driving, keep driving"

I drove 20 minutes to pick her up and take her to Ruby Tuesdays — because that's how I rolled in 2004. As I pulled up, my whole mind was screaming "keep driving, just go home, don't do it." If I could do it over, I'd have floored it. But I'd said I'd go through with it, so I did — and honestly, the only upside is that I've got this story 22 years later.

Surviving dinner on Pulp Fiction quotes

My ego was destroyed. I was terrified my friends had grabbed a table to watch. I wasn't even present — I was performing, cracking myself up with one Pulp Fiction quote after another that she didn't get ("mmm, this is a tasty burger"). I just wanted it to be over. I took her back to her parents' house and, trying not to send mixed signals, told her plainly I wasn't looking to see her again, and drove off.

I got home and told my friends, who were bent over laughing — "you should have kept driving, man." I know, I know. Next time. The good news is I just had an online date a week ago and it went a whole lot better. If you want more stories like this, you can watch my life playlist here.

Want help applying this to your situation?

Schedule a One-on-One Call With Me

$96 for a private 30-minute one-on-one call with me. Pick any time that works for you.

Schedule a one-on-one call with me and bring the exact thing you are stuck on. We can look at your channel, website, AI workflow, ICP setup, book, business, dating pattern, communication, health habits, or next step — and you will leave the call with a clear plan for exactly what to do next.