Jerry Banfield Shop
☰

Being Single vs. a Relationship: My Honest Take on Single Life

Being Single vs. a Relationship: My Honest Take on Single Life

My honest answer is that a healthy relationship is better than being single, and I still hold that view after my own divorce. I don't say that to pretend single life has nothing going for it. I've had about a decade single and 15 years in a relationship, and I'm single again now. I'm enjoying parts of this season: I have a lot of friends, men and women, young and old, and my kids stay with me several nights a week. But I'm under no illusion that single is better. The biggest loss from my divorce was the depth of that partnership.

There is one important limit. I'm not talking about staying in an abusive or hurtful relationship. Being single beats that, and both the June and August posts say so. The question I'm really answering is whether a good partnership beats the comfortable single life that many people settle into, and my answer is yes. Single life can feel safe while it slowly costs you what a partner gives you: a backup plan, shared money, a teammate, and someone on your side when life goes wrong.

In my August 2026 post, Your Single Life Sucks. You're Just Used to It., I use a story from my own work. I was a correction officer in 2006, and the first months were hard. After about six months, the prison started to feel like home. I think single people can go through the same thing: you get used to being single, and then freedom starts to feel strange. The longer you're single, the more your life gets built around being alone, and the harder it becomes to make room for a partner.

My thinking has moved over time, and the three posts show it. The oldest is Learning to Flirt Again After Marriage, a journal entry from September 30, 2025, written in the middle of my divorce as part of my daily autobiography The Kind Divorce. It is about relearning how to approach women after years of keeping my energy friendly but contained. I wanted to get back to that side of myself, with connection first and flirtation second, and without becoming the fixer in someone else's life.

By June 2026, in You're Not Happy Being Single, I had a sharper point. Many single people say they love being single while their lives show something else, and I think that is self-deception. My test is simple: nobody says they love being broke. They say they haven't built the money yet. The first step is admitting you're miserable being single, and then doing the work. I put my own money where my mouth is: I wrote that I had spent more than $10,000 on dating in the six months before that post, and that I go out consistently.

By August 2026 the argument had widened. In that post I say people in relationships tend to be happier, have an easier life and more support, and that men in particular have more to gain from a partnership. I also say it is primarily on men to initiate. Some readers will disagree, and I'd rather you weigh the claims than take my word for them. The posts rest mostly on my own experience and on patterns I have seen, so read them that way.

Below this opening you'll find a contents list and then all three posts in full, newest first. If you want the practical side, my dating mindset notes cover how I approach dating now, and the standards post covers how high is too high. Read them alongside the three posts above and you'll see the single-life question from a few angles.

If you are single and comfortable, I'd ask you one question: what would your life look like with a partner in it, and what is stopping you from finding out?

On this page

Every post I have written on this subject is below in full, newest first, each under its own heading.

  1. Your Single Life Sucks. You’re Just Used to It. (August 18, 2026)
  2. You're Not Happy Being Single (June 13, 2026)
  3. Learning to Flirt Again After Marriage (September 30, 2025)

Your Single Life Sucks. You’re Just Used to It.

From my video published August 18, 2026.

Your single life sucks, but you're just used to it and comfortable there. I'm making this because I am here to help wake you up to my experience that relationships — a life lived in a happy relationship — is the best level you're going to get to. A lot of us know this as teenagers, when we first start having all our hormones and we start trying to date. But a lot of us lose this vision and we give up. I see so many people I know — men, women, old, young — and I can tell you, in my experience, people in relationships are the happiest. People in relationships have life the easiest. People in relationships have a backup plan, a partner, less financial stress, so much more sex and joy. In almost every metric I've seen, people in relationships are better off. Especially — especially — when you remove people in toxic relationships.

So I have an analogy for you that will make this obvious. And if this is tough for you to even hear, good. I'm challenging you to question what you're doing. And I'm here to help. You can schedule a call with me. You can join my chat. I'm here to support you in this transition.

What Working in a Prison Taught Me About Being Single

I was a correction officer in 2006, and the first few months of working in prison absolutely sucked. I was there 40-plus hours a week in prison with the inmates, and those first few months were just hard to tolerate. I hated being in there. I felt like I was locked up with them just because I had the keys. I was in there getting a paycheck, but I still was spending about 25 percent of my time in prison. What's crazy is that after about six months, I started to feel comfortable. I would go into the prison and it started to feel like home. It started to feel like a place I belonged. Thankfully, I got out of there and I got to be a police officer, and that felt so much better than working in prison.

But this is what has happened to so many people who have actually been in prison. They get used to being in prison, and being free feels strange and uncomfortable. There are many people who intentionally re-offend just to go back to prison, where life seems to make sense and be more comfortable. I've come to believe most people's single lives have turned into this same institutionalization, because you get used to being single.

And yes, being single is much better than being in a bad relationship. Never tolerate an abusive, awful relationship. Never tolerate a relationship where you're being disrespected, where you're fighting all the time, where you're making each other's lives worse. But just because that's been your experience with relationships doesn't mean that's what all relationships are like.

The Honeymoon Phase Does Not Have to Wear Off

I was on a date with a woman who told me that the honeymoon phase wears off after three months in a relationship. I said, no, it doesn't — that's ridiculous. My ex-wife and I had years, years of honeymoon phase. Years of it just being awesome to be together — at least I did. And even most of the 15 years we were together were so much better than being single.

Now, my ex and I chose to get divorced because both of us thought we would be more compatible with someone else. I wanted more kids. She didn't. We both agreed that I should find a woman to have more kids with, and that since she said no, she didn't want more kids, she should find a man who didn't want more kids and would be more compatible with her. You see how I am — I'm this very high-energy YouTube guy, very public life, very out-of-the-box thinker. And my ex-wife is a corporate worker who wants a guy that's liberal, that's on her wavelength. The two of us — our initial attraction was that we were opposites. And I got to be kind of weak in my masculinity also, and that turned her off. So we got divorced.

At first she was like, oh, I don't want a relationship — I'm much happier single. She very quickly found that's not true. She's been dating someone the last several months, and it was literally the first guy she went out with from a dating app, because she knows that having a great relationship is way better than being single.

Why I Believe It's on Men to Initiate

I've struggled this last year, because I think as a woman it's a bit easier to be desperate — now, that's just a generalization — but as a woman, it's a bit easier to just kind of throw yourself at a guy and he'll accept you. Whereas when men really want relationships, women often interpret that as desperate, as needy: he's a loser, he has low social value. So as a man who realizes how valuable a relationship is, dating can be quite a challenge. But I think it's primarily on men. We need to be going out there and looking for relationships.

Because if you look at the statistics, women do a bit better out of relationships, while men tend to fare very badly out of them. In almost every statistic you look at, men that are single have, in almost every way, much worse lives than men that are in relationships. I would say relationships actually benefit men generally more than they benefit women, because women generally have better social support from other women, better connections with their family and friends, and lives that are better set up to be single. So to me, it is on men to be going out there and trying to find a woman, because I would say men have much more to gain from a relationship.

Now, women have a ton to gain from relationships as well, and in my experience women generally will be much happier in a relationship too. A lot of the women I meet that are single are so stressed out about their finances, and they're struggling with their moods and their emotions to have a life that actually is meaningful. So many of the women I know that are single are always trying to find themselves. They work so hard, they stress out about work, and then they spend all their money going on trips and trying to fulfill themselves with things that end up being pretty empty. Then they're getting medications and trying to deal with all these mood struggles. From my view, if you had a man that you loved, that also provided financially — and maybe that you had a family with, maybe not — a lot of these other things in your life would go away. So women have a lot to gain also. But men, we need to be initiating things, because a lot of women aren't comfortable going out and asking a man for his phone number.

The Grocery Store Story

Now, I know a woman — and this is as beautiful a woman as you could want to meet — who literally chased a guy down in the parking lot of a grocery store because she'd had a great conversation with him. And he had given up. I've talked to him. He had given up so much on having a relationship. He dated for years after getting divorced, and it was just pain, suffering, and incompatibility from every direction. He had given up for years — given up on even finding a relationship — to the point where he has this great conversation with a beautiful woman in the grocery store and he just walks out, because he figures there's no point even asking for her number. He's like, "I'm going to go get a drink." He gave up. And in this case, the woman actually, literally ran after him in the parking lot and gave him her phone number. They are still together years later today.

I definitely think women need to be making moves like that, because a lot of men have just stuck themselves in these single prison cells. So much content out there is telling men: just withdraw, stay single, the dating game sucks so bad you shouldn't even try it. And that is so disempowering, because men, look at all the data — all the data out there. Men in relationships are much happier, live longer, are healthier, and make more money, because men that are in a relationship with a woman often tend to be motivated to make more money and provide for her. And women in relationships, in my experience, tend to be much more relaxed, much less stressed out — especially about money — with much less of a need to go find themselves, and much more emotionally stable, because a real man will help a woman have a place to ground all her emotions, to feel all her feelings in a safe environment and not feel crazy.

Women Aren't Crazy — That's What You Have to Offer

A lot of guys are screwed up today. I know a guy, a decade older than me, good-looking, very well liked. He goes out with lots of women, and he goes around saying all the women he goes out with are crazy. It's like, do you not understand women? Women have lots of emotions, and it will appear crazy — but that's what you have to offer. I realize women can seem crazy, and I'm extremely consistent, despite what some of you may think. I show up and make videos every day no matter how I feel. I can show up and love a woman every single day no matter how she acts, and I have the grounding. I know what it feels like to feel like a man — I'm very grounded, consistent, and undisturbable. And I know what it feels like to feel like a woman in a relationship, which I did with my ex — to feel all my emotions and feel like I need my partner to help me be okay. That was one of the dynamics behind why we needed to get divorced.

The First Step Is Awareness

So the bottom line here is that life is much happier in relationships, and this is important: the first step is awareness — realizing that you're being dishonest with yourself, going around saying that you don't know what you want in dating, that you're unhappy with relationships, that you don't even need someone in your life.

And it's amazing how single moms especially seem to be in this rut. I have two single moms I just reached out to last night. Neither of them messaged me back. These are women that, as far as I know, are not dating anyone else. They're very single. And yet they're just in a rut. They're used to being single. They've taken on this masculine "I'm going to do all of it, I'm going to provide for my kids" — but then they're stressed out, then they're lonely, then they don't have any backup there. And the thing that sucks is that from there, it's harder to get into a relationship. Like this one single mom I just reached out to last night: on the surface, if you look at her Instagram, she's attractive, she's successful, she has a business. But if you dig into the personal details, her life and relationships are a mess — breaking up with the same guy a whole bunch of times, not even knowing what she wants in dating. And then here's a guy her friend recommended.

I sent a text message saying hi, and she didn't even respond to it. That's the problem. So many of our hearts are stuck in prison, and they've just taken being in prison as what's normal. The crazy thing is, when somebody opens the cell door, they don't even walk out. In fact, they're scared: "Oh, it's dangerous out there. I might get hurt." It's like you're settling for this solitary confinement. And yes, the solitary confinement might feel safe. But to me, the biggest danger is to get to the end of your life and realize you pissed your life away.

The Longer You're Single, the Harder It Gets

I see a lot of people in their 60s, 70s, 80s who haven't had a relationship in decades. And the longer you go single, it tends to be more and more difficult, because you get to be more and more set in your ways, more and more unable to build a partnership. Like the woman I went out with — she's been single a lot of her life; she's had a relationship for a few years at least. And I told her, to me, the main thing I need to qualify a woman on is: are you willing to give up your single life and be a part of something bigger than you, where your life is not all about you and what you want?

Like when I went out with the queen that I talk about in some of my older content — she's been single basically her whole life, never had a long-term relationship. And that's something I should have seen. She's been single for a long time, and I see it now: you just don't know how to be a teammate with somebody, to not put everything you want first and foremost all the time, and to kind of surrender. She told me she's run from every guy that liked her. And that's what we need to stop doing. We need to give people a chance. We need to at least try relationships. Even if it doesn't work, okay — maybe you learned something.

But the problem is that the longer you're single, the more you start to adapt your whole life to it. Like the woman I dated a month ago who's been single essentially her whole life — her whole life is set up to be single. She has all these things she does, she has all these people, and she doesn't have space for a relationship. She made space for me the first week, but then the rest of her life was competing. She does all these activities, and many of them are nice, but a lot of them are just not enough — and I think that's a waste of time that's set up to fill space, so she doesn't have to look at how single she is and how lonely she is. Then when somebody else comes in, dating starts to feel inconvenient: "Well, I don't want to hang out with him, I've got all this other stuff I want to do." And then she's all stressed about money — when if she'd make a partnership with me, money wouldn't be a concern anymore. It is so much more expensive to be single than to have a partner. If I could easily have a woman move into this house, both of us would save thousands of dollars a month. That's a lot of time working every month.

"I'm Better Off Alone" — Says Who?

So a lot of people's single lives have turned into "oh, I'm better off alone." And then you watch a bunch of content that tells you, yeah, you're better off alone, dating sucks, it's humiliating. And in the short term, that actually leaves you feeling better. A lot of people reading this will feel bad. You'll start to feel confused. You'll start to feel like, oh, I'm better off alone. You'll start to feel dumb. You'll start to feel sad. And a lot of people run from those feelings — just like a lot of people that have been single a long time run from feelings of love and joy and connection and interpret it as pressure. "He's pressuring me." It's like, yeah, I'm pressuring you to stop being a lonely, sad person and to become part of something bigger — a team — to build a bigger life than just you trying to survive.

And yet it's this kind of conversation that will change someone's life. This kind of conversation will get you thinking and get you honestly looking at your life and being like, damn, is he right about me? Have I gotten to the point where I forgot how much I wanted love, and wanted to be loved, at some point? Have I given up on being happy? Is being single really something that's okay? And I believe it's not.

Most people, you get to the end of your life — imagine some of these people. I focus on a lot of women, but there are a lot of guys too, great guys I know, who've never had a long-term relationship either, and it'd be sad to think of them getting old alone. Men actually have more time, because women tend to like older men — I do have a family member that found love in her 60s — so men often have more time to kind of screw around and be single. But women, in my experience, if you don't find a man you fall in love with and make a great relationship with by the time your 30s and 40s are over, often that's it. If you don't make the most of your 20s, 30s, and 40s, you'll often be so comfortable and locked into being single that you generally won't be able to have a partnership with somebody ever again. Like this woman I dated — I think if she doesn't find someone soon, she's probably going to be single the whole rest of her life. And that's sad, because life is better lived together.

Life Is Better Lived Together

Life is better with somebody next to you in bed. Life is better with a teammate — if you lose your job, they've got a job. And it feels better to help other people: if your partner loses their job, you're their backup plan. That feels better.

So if you enjoyed this, or if you felt a lot of emotions and you want help with that, you want support with that — I am leading by example. I'm going through the pain of dating myself, especially when I'm very aware that being in a relationship is so much better. That makes dating harder. It makes it high stakes. I share the whole journey on my Dating playlist if you want to follow along.

If you want to talk to me, join the family in my chat — you can talk to me all day, every day — or schedule a Zoom call with me.

And I'm putting a dating coaching package up on my website to help those of you that have been single a long time: break out of your single routines, take inventory, get your heart opening, and get ready to date.

You're Not Happy Being Single

From my video published June 13, 2026.

I recently watched a woman post a video about how lonely she is — and in the same breath insist on how happy she is being single. Everything else told the opposite story: her expression, her other videos, the way she described sitting home alone on Friday and Saturday nights, up until two or three in the morning watching Carl Jung lectures and telling herself other people just don't think deeply enough for her. Then came the conclusion: "I just like being single. Nobody bothers me, and I get to live my adult life." It doesn't add up, and I think a lot of single people are running the same script.

Step one is honesty

The first thing to do is be honest with yourself: you're miserable being single. That kind of honesty isn't a problem — it's the opening, because once you admit it, you know what to do about it. The trap is self-deception. When you go around insisting "I'm so happy being lonely," you bury the very thing you'd have to face to change it.

I can say this from both sides. I've had about a decade single and 15 years in a relationship, and I'm single again now. I'm genuinely enjoying this season — I have a ton of friends, men and women, young and old, and my kids stay with me several nights a week. But I'm under no illusion that single is better. When I got divorced, the biggest loss by far was the depth of that relationship, and I was very aware of being unhappy by comparison.

Relationships are wealth

Here's the frame that makes it click for me: the highest level you'll ever reach in life is always with other people. Relationships are wealth, and a great partner is a massive form of it. Yes, there are small perks to being single — I get to keep only the healthy food I want in the house instead of the ultra-processed stuff someone else might buy — but I'd move the right woman in tomorrow, because I know how much happier a great relationship is. If you've never had a decade with someone where you were never lonely, you may not even know what you're missing.

This is different from staying in something dysfunctional. If a relationship is hurtful and mean, being single absolutely beats it. But a healthy relationship isn't what you're comparing against when you tell yourself you're fine alone.

"I love being single" is like "I love being broke"

Put it in money terms and the self-deception gets obvious. Imagine someone saying, "I love being broke. I can't afford anything, and I get to complain and feel like a victim." You'd know instantly they don't love it — they just haven't put in the work to have money. Having money is great. Security is great. Dating is the same: it's the equivalent of having a job you genuinely love. Friends and family matter enormously, but in this analogy they're the side hustles, the investments, the inheritance. A loving partnership is the foundational, number-one way you bring real relationship wealth — love, joy, and connection — into your life.

Do the work

So get honest, and then go to work. I've spent more than $10,000 on dating in the last six months and I go out consistently — I've got dates lined up this week. One of these connections is going to turn into marriage, more kids, and building an awesome life together, and that is so much better than being single that it's hard to even describe waking up next to a partner you love and getting to do life together. Is dating hard? Of course. A woman I matched with on a dating app told me the same thing this week, and she's right. But hard isn't a reason to quit — building a business I love was hard too, and it was worth every bit of it. The work is worth doing. I went deeper on how my own approach to all this has changed in I can't date like I did 15 years ago, and you can find more in my dating videos here.

Learning to Flirt Again After Marriage

Originally published September 30, 2025.

This is my journal entry from September 30, 2025, part of my daily autobiography The Kind Divorce — my real, unedited days, published in order.

I took the kids to school this morning, reading my son a few pages from his newest space book that he’d checked out from the library before drop-off. It’s one of the little rituals I love most—those quiet, curious moments before the rush of the day begins.

When I got home, my ex-wife and I sat down for a long, beautiful hour-long talk about our future. We’re both genuinely happy with where things are heading. She’s relieved to have space and freedom again, and I’m grateful we’ve managed to build such peace into this process. She cried a little when I told her I wanted to make financial amends for all the years I’d spent doing whatever I wanted with money without truly collaborating. It felt healing for both of us—to acknowledge the imbalance and start righting those wrongs before I move forward into the next chapter of my life.

After our conversation, I went to my tennis lesson with my tennis coach at the tennis club. I walked the entire complex—all sixteen courts—before I finally found him on the first one, which he almost never uses. It had been a week since I’d last played, and it felt great to be out there again, hitting ball after ball, letting my body find its rhythm. About halfway through the lesson, I told my tennis coach about the divorce. His reaction was simple and kind—he said it sounded like we were both being really mature about it. I agreed. What strikes me now is how much that is a choice. We could just as easily make it ugly. But it helps so much that we’re both on the same page. Trying to be calm and fair while the other person is melting down would be brutal. I’m deeply grateful for how mature my ex-wife has been through all of this.

After tennis, I came home and threw myself into editing I Was Famous on the Internet again. I’d love to have it live on Amazon by this weekend. This feels like the final pass—the one that pulls everything together. My ex-wife was picking up the kids, so I had the house to myself for a bit, which gave me time to take two calls from friends that came at the perfect moment.

One of them was a friend—one of my very first readers after yoga one day at my yoga studio. I remember he wanted to buy Author in St. Petersburg and Speaker Meeting 2017. I usually give Author in St. Petersburg away, but he insisted on paying, and all he had was a $20 bill. So I told him he could take both books for $20—a buy-one-get-one deal.

He called to check on me, but also to tell me something that made me laugh. A woman had sat next to him in an open room at my yoga studio and started talking to him. She mentioned she had two kids and was looking for a man who wanted more kids. He said she was beautiful. I told him months ago that exactly this kind of thing would happen if he started showing up to yoga regularly—there are so many amazing women there and not nearly enough grounded, single men. Hearing his story felt like confirmation that the kind of woman I’m looking for—someone who could become my next partner, maybe even my next wife—is already looking for me too, maybe has been for longer than I’ve realized.

Talking to him made me recognize something important: I’ll need to shift my approach. After years of being married, I’ve trained myself to keep my energy friendly but contained—to never let it cross into anything suggestive, flirty, or remotely sexual. It feels strange now to encourage my mind to move back in that direction. When I was single, that energy was automatic. I’d meet a woman and immediately ask if she was single, and often, I’d ask for her number with a clear dating intention.

I don’t want to swing that far back, but I do want to consciously reawaken that side of myself. This time, I want connection first, flirtation second. I want to really see a girl before deciding to pursue her. But I’m grateful that I have the awareness to know this is a transition—to recognize that the way I relate to women is something I’ll need to relearn, and that I’m ready to do it with intention. If you’re relearning how to relate after a long relationship too, you can set up a call with me and we’ll talk through these transitions without any pretense.

There were so many times I saw girls at my yoga studio who were breathtakingly beautiful—open, friendly, smiling at me—and if I’d been single, I would’ve made sure to talk to them. But being married changed that. I’d look at a woman and think, She’s gorgeous, but there’s no reason to go there. Don’t start something you can’t finish. Even so, I still found myself developing a few crushes and forming some genuine friendships there. Now that I’m single again, I feel a real excitement about what comes next in my dating life. There’s this new curiosity, this sense of possibility.

Before my ex-wife got home with the kids, I went to my 4 p.m. AA meeting. We had a solid discussion—two newcomers and three of us regulars. It was a great mix, and the conversation flowed easily. Afterward, I came home, tidied up around the house, and played Uno No Mercy with the kids before bedtime. Once they were asleep, I spent about half an hour talking to my mom, mostly listening as she shared what was going on in her life.

Later, my ex-wife and I had another good talk before bed. It amazes me how much tension used to fill that time of night between us. Bedtime was often the only window in the day when we might have sex, and that created pressure on both sides. Sometimes it went beautifully—she’d be playful and we’d have fun—but other nights it felt heavy, like something we had to get through instead of something we both wanted. It’s astonishing how peaceful our conversations have become now that sex is no longer hanging in the air.

At the same time, I feel this new wave of excitement knowing there are probably a hundred women in St. Petersburg who I’d be deeply compatible with—women who would actually want to have sex with me before bed, and often. I imagine finding a partner who matches my energy and wants an active, connected life together.

I also recognize that I’m not everyone’s type. Being a man who doesn’t drink, doesn’t play video games, doesn’t watch TV, isn’t into concerts or bars, and doesn’t listen to music—well, that immediately filters out a huge portion of the dating pool. But it also filters in the women who will appreciate that. I know there are women who’ll light up when I say I’d love to go to a yoga class at my yoga studio, play tennis, explore the Dalí Museum downtown, sit together in a park, cook dinner, read books, play board games, or enjoy an active, intimate life together. Somewhere out there, there are women who’ll find that lifestyle perfect.

I’ve accepted that I’m not right for anyone who craves drama. I’m too grounded now for that. I’m not a fixer-upper anymore like I was when my ex-wife and I first met. Back then, she had to stabilize me. Today, I’ve got my life together, and that can be intimidating or unappealing to some women. I see it all the time—women dating men who clearly don’t have it together. They must be drawn to the chaos, because if they didn’t want to deal with it, they wouldn’t.

What gives me pause is the possibility that I might flip the dynamic—that I could become the “fixer” in my next relationship. I don’t want to date a woman who’s lost in addiction or dysfunction and try to rescue her. I’d much rather meet someone who already has her own life in order, so we can build something peaceful, playful, and fulfilling together—with no drama, no codependency, just joy. If you notice yourself slipping into the fixer role in your own dating life, you can book a one-on-one call with me and we’ll talk through your patterns together.

I let my ex-wife go at 10:15 so she could get to bed early—she wakes up at 5:30 a.m.—and then I dove back into I Was Famous on the Internet for another hour before finally calling it a night at 11:15.

If you connect with how I live and think, you can follow the rest of my days on YouTube in my Dating playlist.

Want me to make a video for you?

Send me your YouTube channel, business, crypto project, video, dating profile, or question. I record a video with my honest thoughts and send it to you privately.

Get a personal video review

Or schedule a one-hour call → · See everything in the store →